Has it really been 30 years since Anthology was released?

by Bruce Spizer

Anthology – The Beatles Official Store

A little over two years ago on September 27, 2023, I had the pleasure of attending a listening session for what was dubbed as “the last Beatles song,” “Now And Then.” I was deeply moved by both the recording and Peter Jackson’s brilliant video. As “Now And Then” was initially in the running to join “Free As A Bird” and “Real Love” as part of the Beatles “Anthology” project, I naturally thought back to hearing those two recordings for the first time in November 1995 as part of the “Anthology” television special, as well as the excitement I felt purchasing and listening to “Anthology 1,” “Anthology 2” and “Anthology 3.”

During the question and answer session following the screening of the “Now And Then” video, then-Apple CEO Jeff Jones hinted that a revamped “Anthology” was in the works. I wondered what that release would entail. I was aware of Apple’s partnership with Disney, so I assumed that Disney would be streaming an expanded (and perhaps re-edited) “Anthology” video. As for the music, I hoped that the existing “Anthology” releases would be remastered and remixed utilizing today’s technology, including using Machine-Assisted-Learning (“MAL”) software to improve the primitive-sounding early tracks. Maybe some of the selections would be re-edited to restore songs to their full length or to fix a few annoying things such as an edit having Paul talking over the spoken introduction to “My Bonnie.” (In case you haven’t checked, it remains the same.) I also figured that there would be some new outtakes added from the group’s albums that had yet to receive the deluxe edition treatment. That would include the albums “Please Please Me” through “Rubber Soul” plus tracks from “Magical Mystery Tour” and “Yellow Submarine.”

image002-2.jpg

This speculation made me realize that a revised and expanded “Anthology” could indeed be a worthy project, but I wondered: “Why ‘Anthology’ now?” After all, it wasn’t that long ago that “Anthology” made its debut. But then I realized that “Anthology” was nearly 30 years old! That meant that it came out before many young Beatles fans were listening to music or were even born! So, yeah, maybe the time was right to bring “Anthology” to a new generation and, at the same time, give first and second generation fans a reason to revisit the project.

It is worth noting that while I played each new “Anthology” CD-set over and over again upon their release, I have only listened to the sets a dozen or so times during the past 20 years, and that was usually in conjunction with my writing books on the Beatles. Although each “Anthology” set is full of great music, I prefer hearing the Beatles music organized around the recording sessions for each album as opposed to a career overview of interesting outtakes mixed with live performances. For that reason, I have concentrated my listening on the deluxe edition box sets that began with 2017’s “Sgt. Pepper” 50th Anniversary Edition.

That said, I recognize that Apple must market the Beatles to the younger audiences. Failure to do so could very well lead to the group being viewed as a relic of the past. I remember a cartoon of a customer in a record store asking where the Beatles records were and being told to check the classical music section, so I understand Apple’s strategy. But I still hope Apple will continue with releases that will appeal to the group’s aging fan base that I am proudly a part of!

When “Anthology” was set for release in 1995, George Harrison wryly provided this spot-on description: “It is both a record, a video, a television program, a book and, no doubt, somewhere down the line it will also be a T-shirt.” It did not take long for “Anthology” T-shirts. This time around, it is a record (and CD and streaming), a video to stream on Disney+, a book, a T-shirt (multiple designs), a layered long-sleeve shirt, hoodies (multiple styles), denim jackets (one for each of the original three “Anthology” covers), caps, tote bags, slip mats for your turntable (one for each of the original three “Anthology” covers), and an “Anthology” lithograph incorporating the three original covers, all conveniently available on Anthology – The Beatles Official Store

  The 2025 edition of the “Anthology” book is the easiest to discuss. If you already own the first edition book, there is no need to buy the “new” book unless your original copy is severely worn or you are a truly obsessive collector. The 2025 version of the book is virtually identical to the first edition.

As for purchasing the music, it depends upon factors such as your budget, your age, your collector’s mentality and your desire to hear the recordings at their best. If price is not a factor and you have a turntable, I recommend obtaining the 12-LP vinyl box set containing the four “Anthology” triple albums. If you prefer CDs, then you can buy all four 2-CD sets. If you have a limited budget, then the “Anthology 4” 2-CD stand-alone set may be the way to go.

For longtime fans, “Anthology 4” will generate the most interest. The good news is that it contains 13 new tracks. The bad news is that it contains 13 new tracks as in “only 13 new tracks.” Those who are upset by this decision must understand that Apple selected the recordings keeping in mind that many of the people purchasing or streaming this set do not already own “The Beatles Bootleg Recordings 1963” or the five deluxe edition box sets of the group’s later albums. For them, most of the tracks on “Anthology 4” will be new to their ears.

Side 1 of the vinyl set opens with two selections from “The Beatles Bootleg Recordings 1963.” Take 2 of “I Saw Her Standing There” is a fun and exciting performance that was not suitable for release on the group’s first album due to the boys getting their “I” and “she” pronouns mixed up in the lyrics. “Money” is presented with RM7 (remix mono 7) prior to overdubs such as George Martin’s piano. It shows the raw energy of the band live in the studio. The next track, “This Boy” Takes 12 and 13, was first issued on the “Free As A Bird” EP released along with “Anthology 1” in 1995. Once again, the takes are fun but not ready for prime time. While the harmonies are quite pleasing, the boys have trouble remembering where to sing “this boy” or “that boy” in a few places.

The remainder of Side 1 contains five new outtakes. Prior to the boys performing Take 4 of “Tell Me Why,” John instructs George on how to sing his harmony part. After Take 4 quickly breaks down, Paul admonishes: “Yeah, you’ve done it again. You made a mistake, I know you did!” The group then runs through an energetic Takes 5 with tight harmonies. At the end of the second bridge, John falls into a muffled laugh singing the final word, “you,” and Paul shouts out “yes!” leading into the final verse. It’s fascinating to hear the group working to get that perfect take for the master, but not quite pulling it off. This exciting live-in-the-studio performance makes one wonder why the band never performed the song in concert or for the BBC.

Take 11 of “If I Fell” is preceded by John looking to encourage the group by saying: “We’re on the air, folks. Come on!” The take has John tapping the beat on his acoustic guitar during his solo vocal introduction. This unnecessary “percussion” would fortunately be dropped by the time the master was recorded. The harmonies are tight, but John and Paul screw up the words during the second bridge. Although Ringo has worked out how he will introduce his drums into the song just before John begins singing the verses, he plays it straight thereafter, not yet adding the fills leading into the later verses. Similarly, George has yet to incorporate his lead guitar phrases into the space between verses; however, he does have his closing harmonic notes worked out fairly well. As the song’s end, he asks: “Something like that?” Yes George, something like that.

“Matchbox” Take 1 has a raw, rocking vocal from Ringo, who at times sings different words during the verses than on the master issued in 1964. For this take, he sings “I said I’m sittin’ here watchin’ matchbox hole in my clothes” twice in the first verse, whereas on the master take he sings “wonderin'” instead of “watchin'” the second time around. He starts off the second verse with “I’m an ole poor boy and I ain’t got a home” before singing the second line as “I’m an ole poor boy and I’m a long way from home” as he does both times on the master. He closes the verse with “And everything I do turns out mighty wrong” instead of “I’ve never been happy cause everything I ever did was wrong” as on the master. During the third verse, he changes “please don’t shake my tree” to “please don’t shake Ringo’s tree” for the second line. At the end of this verse, he shouts what sounds like “All right, John” before Lennon takes the guitar solo instead of George, who solos on the master. Finally, Ringo also muffs the last line “watch how your puppy dog runs” during the fourth verse.

Takes 6 and 7 of “Every Little Thing” have the group closing in on a successful backing track but not quite pulling it off. John and Paul sing live over George strumming his Gibson Jumbo acoustic-electric guitar, Paul on bass, and Ringo on drums. After Take 6 breaks down, Paul says he just burped. John complains to engineer Norman Smith about not being able to get close to the mike to sing. At the start of Take 7, the space where the opening guitar riff will later be recorded is tapped out in 16 beats. This take is complete but contains laughter towards the end. After the Beatles recorded an acceptable backing with Take 9, John overdubbed his opening and closing lead guitar riffs and solo on his custom Rickenbacker 325-12 electric 12-string guitar, while Paul superimposed low piano notes on every third line of each verse and at the end of the solo, and Ringo added accenting timpani drum beats during the chorus. Some listeners shall “hear in their mind” these yet-to-be-recorded embellishments while listening to Take 7.

Prior to the start of Take 1 of “I Need You,” George instructs the group with “Not too fast.” Although this take is indeed faster than the later-recorded master, Harrison provides a solid live vocal over his strumming on his Gibson Jumbo acoustic-electric guitar. He would switch to his nylon string guitar for later takes. Paul provides an active bass part in tandem with Ringo’s drums, while John shakes maracas. Later takes would feature Ringo keeping time on the back of a Jumbo acoustic guitar while John hit the snare drum on the offbeat. Ringo would overdub cowbell on the bridge for the master take. During this initial performance, John and Paul do not provide backing vocals. Midway through, John can be heard laughing in the background. As the song continues, John’s laughter increases, leading Ringo to shout out what sounds like a playful “Fu*k off, John.” This causes George, who is singing “what you mean to me” to fight from laughing as he sings “me.” At this stage, the song concluded with a typical rock ‘n’ roll ending that would be reworked for the master.

Side 2 starts out strong with three new outtakes from “Rubber Soul.” Take 3 of “I’ve Just Seen A Face” is quite close to the master take. After a quick false start, George starts the song with bass notes on John’s Framus Hootenanny acoustic guitar with Paul falling in with a triplet pattern moving up the neck of his Epiphone Tennessean acoustic guitar before switching to strumming behind his near-perfect lead vocal. George’s guitar solo is fully developed but missing the harmonics at the end. John provides powerful strumming throughout, announcing at the end: “I broke a string.”

Prior to recording “In My Life,” John comments “these Fenders are so heavy,” indicating that he and most likely George are playing their new Fender Stratocasters on the song. Take 1 has live John and Paul vocals with a tight instrumental backing that leaves space for an instrumental solo that George Martin would later fill with sped-up piano that sounds like a harpsichord. It is clear from this recording that the group had worked out the entire arrangement in advance, delivering an excellent performance on their first take that could have been used as the master.

The Beatles first attempted “Nowhere Man” on October 21. After a false start (not provided here), the group recorded Take 2 with John, Paul and George singing the opening two lines of the song in harmony before performing a strictly instrumental backing with John on his Jumbo, George on his electric 12-string Rickenbacker, Paul on bass and Ringo on drums. This arrangement is reminiscent of the Byrds. The phrasing of the first line is sung differently than on the finished master. When the group remade the song the following day, George played his six-string Fender Stratocaster.

The remainder of the side has the following songs from the deluxe editions of “Revolver” and “Sgt. Pepper”: “Got To Get You Into My Life,” “Love You To,” “Strawberry Fields Forever,” and “She’s Leaving Home.”

Side 3 contains all new outtakes, starting with Takes 11 and 12 of “Baby, You’re A Rich Man.” Take 11 starts with George on guitar played through a rotating Leslie speaker, Paul on piano, and Ringo on drums. After a few measures, the song stops and Paul says “Gotta get in tune, George.” After a quick tuning, the trio starts again but once again quickly breaks down. George then asks, “Is that how the beginning goes?” Paul tells George “G to C.” After he and George play some chords, Paul asks John, who is in the control booth, “Should we just do drums and piano on this one?” John replies, “Yeah, that guitar’s a curse, man.” John asks roadie Mal Evans to bring in some Cokes, while Paul requests “cannabis resin, too,” with John in agreement. Paul then jokes, “We got that taped for the High Court tomorrow.” His dialog is most likely influenced by Mick Jagger and Keith Richards’ Court appearance the day before on drug charges.

After the engineer calls out “Take 12,” Paul plays some chords, says “They put you up when you know it’s 12,” and comments on how loud it is in the studio. John then sings, “How does it feel to be one of the loudest people?,” and adds, “All right, let’s hear some rhythm and soul from London now, please, come along.” This selection continues with Paul and Ringo’s piano and drum backing track with overdubbed bass by Paul, and John and Paul’s vocals. They are clearly having fun singing the song, with John sometimes rolling the “r” as he sings “rich man.” These vocals would later be recorded over. When the song ends with some piano flourishes by Paul, John asks, “How do you feel about that, boys?” After Paul tells him, “We got swinging,” John asks him if he wants to hear it back, to which Paul replies, “Yes.” John adds: “All right. We’ll hear it back, then.” The studio banter shows the boys were having fun with this one, which was originally intended for the “Yellow Submarine” cartoon but instead ended up being the B-side to “All You Need Is Love.”

Next up is a rehearsal for “All You Need Is Love” taped the day before the Beatles contribution to the television special Our World. Prior to the practice performance, the BBC commentator reads the introduction that would be used for the live broadcast. After a false start, George Martin gives out instructions to the boys and the orchestra, while John adds, “Queen Margaret was wearing a low-feathered nightgown.” During the song, John ad-libs some scat vocals throughout the “Love, love, love” refrains preceding the verses and mimics the brass part during the first part of some of the verses. The rehearsal has the orchestra playing along, including David Mason’s trumpet solo and the orchestral strands of “Greensleeves” and “In The Mood” during song’s protracted ending, which also has a guitar part by George that is not heard in the final mix. John throws in ad-libbed vocals as the song heads towards its conclusion, including his end-bit “Anybody got a bit of money, anybody got a bit of money” refrain that was previously heard in Take 11 of “Taxman” appearing on “Anthology 2.”

Take 5 of “The Fool On The Hill” is a fascinating instrumental backing that fills in a missing gap on how the song evolved in the studio. “Anthology 2” contains Paul’s live piano and vocal solo demo taped at EMI Studios on September 6, 1967, as well as Take 4 of the song recorded by the group on September 25. Take 5 is a re-make from the following day recorded over four tracks that would subsequently be mixed down to a single track to form the basis of Take 6, which would be subjected to numerous overdubs. This instrumental recording has pianos, acoustic guitars, celeste, recorders, drums, maracas and finger cymbals treated with tape delay, much of which is heard in the version of the song issued on the “Magical Mystery Tour” British EP and American album. At this stage, the song was 4:25 long. It would be edited down to 2:57 for the finished master.

The side ends with a stereo isolation of the strings, horns, and contra bass clarinet recorded for “I Am The Walrus” on the afternoon of September 27, 1967. The song’s electric piano introduction, John’s vocal and Ringo’s drums were picked up by the microphones recording these embellishments and can be faintly heard in the background. This take, designated 19, was the second attempt by the sessions musicians and was not used for the mixing of the master.

Side 4 opens with the final new track on the album, Take 4 of “Hey Bulldog,”recorded on February 11, 1968. This instrumental backing features John on piano, George on guitar, Ringo on drums and Paul hitting two tambourines. After a few measures, John stops and says, “I didn’t like the rhythm, actually.” John then does a count-in followed by two piano chords before stopping and doing a second count-in leading to a performance that is close to the master recording. John’s guide vocal, picked by the piano microphone, is barely audible. At the song’s conclusion, John says, “Veering between yer blues and yer comedy.” The finished master, with John and Paul’s ad-libbed barks, howls, shouts, gurgles and other vocal effects, veers closer to “yer comedy.” As for “yer blues,” John would use that as the title for one of his songs recorded later that year for “The White Album.”

The remainder of this side contains the following recordings from the deluxe edition of “The White Album”: “Good Night,” “While My Guitar Gently Weeps,” “(You’re So Square) Baby I Don’t Care,” “Helter Skelter,” “I Will,” “Can You Take Me Back?” and “Julia.”

Side 5 has the following selections from the deluxe editions of “Let It Be” and “Abbey Road”: “Get Back,” “Octopus’s Garden,” “Don’t Let Me Down,” “You Never Give Me Your Money,” “Here Comes The Sun,” and “Something.”

Thee final side of “Anthology 4” is a real treat. It contains the three songs featuring Paul, George and Ringo recording behind a John Lennon vocal. The first two, which first appeared on “Anthology 1 and 2,”  are fresh remixes by Jeff Lynne utilizing MAL software that had yet to be conceived much less developed 30 years ago. John’s vocal on “Free As A Bird” has been beautifully isolated, sounding warmer and less tinny than on the original mix from 1995. The entire song sounds fabulous. “Real Love” features a John lead vocal pulled from two different source. Previous mixes of the song used only one source tape for John’s vocal. His voice sounds better than on the earlier version. While the new mix is noticeably superior in many ways to its 1996 incarnation, some fans prefer the original, which features different George guitar phrases in some places. The good news is that you can still listen to the 1996 mix on the 1996 and 2025 pressings of “Anthology 2” if that is your preference. (It should be noted that some fans believe that the song’s best mix is on the 2015 Blu-ray edition of “Beatles 1+.”) “Anthology 4” appropriately ends with “the last Beatles song,” “Now And Then.” 

Those who buy the 2025 releases of “Anthology 1,” “Anthology 2” and “Anthology 3” will hear noticeably better-sounding versions of several of the tracks. This is primarily due to many recordings being remixed using the same MAL software used for Peter Jackson’s “Get Back” documentary and subsequent Beatles releases. The software isolates each vocal and instrument, enabling fresh mixes from stereo, mono and even poor-fidelity sources. The biggest improvements are, not surprisingly, on the earlier recordings such as the two Quarrymen songs, “That’ll Be The Day” and “In Spite Of All The Danger,” the songs record at Paul’s 20 Forthlin Road home in 1960, “Hallelujah, I Love Her So,” “You’ll Be Mine” and “Cayenne,” and the live recordings. Several of the mono tracks from the original “Anthology” releases now have various amounts of stereo ambience. For example, Take 4 of “Mr. Moonlight” was in mono on the earlier release but now is in stereo. These enhancements give the “Anthology” albums, particularly the first one, a more even sound leading to a more pleasant listening experience. 

The “Anthology” video component was originally broadcast by the ABC television network on the evenings of Sunday, November 19, Wednesday, November 22, and Thursday, November 23, 1995. Each broadcast consisted of two parts. These six parts were shown as six separate weekly episodes on ITV when broadcast in the U.K. from November 26 through December 31, 1995.

The video was first released as physical product on September 5, 1996, in the VHS tape and LaserDisc formats. This new edit consisted of eight parts and included five hours of additional programming. In 2003, “Anthology” was issued in a DVD box set containing the eight episodes from the 1996 edition on four discs plus a fifth disc containing 81 minutes of new footage of the three surviving Beatles and George Martin discussing the “Anthology” project as it was being filmed, including discussions on the recording of “Free As A Bird” and “Real Love.” It also contains wonderful footage of the three surviving Beatles running through some of the songs that influenced them in their early days, as well as the three with George Martin at Abbey Road listening to isolated tracks of Beatles recordings.

Thirty years after its initial broadcast, a re-edited version of the nine episodes was made available for streaming on Disney+, with episodes 1-3 debuting on November 26, episodes 4-6 on November 27, and episodes 7-9 on November 28. This latest version of “Anthology” clearly looks and sounds significantly better than the original broadcast and the subsequent physical releases. The only drawback is that all eight episodes have been shortened during editing even though they contain some new sequences. The comparable running times are as follows (2003 DVD/Disney+): Episode 1 (79 minutes/62 minutes); E2 (72/54); E3 (76/60); E4 (71/54); E5 (72/55); E6 (71/58); E7 (74/60); E8 (81/53); and E9 (81/51). And while most reviews have focused on, praised and described Episode 9 as being new, much of its content was previously issued on the bonus fifth disc in the 2003 DVD release or in the promotional video for “Now And Then.” Be that as it may, Episode 9 is truly is a joy to watch and helps put the “Anthology” project in its proper perspective.

I have not had the time to re-watch the entire 2003 “Anthology” DVD to do a full comparison with the Disney+ edit. I did compare the treatment of the “Hey Jude” segment. The promotional video of the group performing the song was permanently seared into my brain the evening I saw the clip on The Smothers Brothers Comedy Hour back in the fall of 1968. On the DVD, “Hey Jude” is preceded by Paul talking about the inspiration for the song and how John convinced him to leave in a line that Paul initially viewed as needing replacement. The first part of the song is uninterrupted, but the joyous sing-along of the second part cuts away to each Beatles talking about how the group was growing apart, with Ringo coming in at the end and comparing the Beatles breakup to a divorce. This upset me in 1995 and even now as it destroys the uplifting feeling of the song.

The Disney+ treatment is less of a downer, but has even more interruptions. Unlike the DVD version, the Disney+ edit has a brief David Frost introduction. Paul’s comments about “Hey Jude” are now heard during the first part of the song, which is faded down to accommodate Paul’s dialog. The second part of the song no longer has the depressing talk of the impending breakup, but is interrupted by comments by George Martin and Paul. I found myself less annoyed by this intrusion because the dialog was not depressing and because I know I can now watch the complete unedited “Hey Jude” performance on the video version of “Beatles 1.” 

There are obsessive fans who will no doubt assemble detailed comparisons between the 2003 DVD and the Disney+ edit. While that may be fascinating, it misses the point. When I played part of my DVDs, I was disappointed with how it looked and sounded compared to the new Disney+ edit, which will now be considered the definitive version. While some of the stories and songs cut from the DVD version will be missed, none are essential to the telling of the Beatles story by the Beatles themselves. If the cuts bother you and you want to see more, you can still play the DVDs. But be forewarned, they will not look or sound that great after you have experienced the new version.

There is much to savor in the new edit of the “Anthology” video. You sense the closeness of the group through the first eight episodes, and the remaining bonds among the three survivors in Episode 9. You realize that there will come at time when only one remains and then none. But that will not be the end. George Harrison provides the following insightful summation of the act we’ve known for all these years: “The Beatles will just, you know, will go on and on, on those records and films and videos and books and in people’s memories and minds. The Beatles has just become its own thing now. And the Beatles, I think, exist even without us.”

6 Comments

  1. Ed on December 12, 2025 at 11:48 am

    Very thourgh! ! Excellent review fun read.

  2. Jeff Janulis on December 12, 2025 at 11:52 am

    Great article, Bruce. Thanks! Jeff jjanulis@att.net

  3. Barry Eldridge on December 12, 2025 at 1:04 pm

    I think you should give Anthology your full book album details I Known I would buy it. skip the fluff and dig into details for us long time Beatle fans prefer. I do enjoy your work and hav e just about all of them.Thank You.Barry Eldridge

  4. Dan S. on December 12, 2025 at 2:02 pm

    Unless I missed it (and I was looking for it) my favorite moment from the original Anthology was edited out. Jools Holland asked George “What is it like to be a Beatle?” George replied “You tell me what it’s like not to be a Beatle,” and elaborated that the life we live is the only one we know. It was a brilliant observation by George and a perspective that had never occurred to me.

  5. Sue M on December 12, 2025 at 2:53 pm

    Loved that summary. Have watched all episodes now and am going to enjoy listening to the music. Thanks for the great analysis.

  6. G. Steven Cleere on December 12, 2025 at 6:17 pm

    Wow, it has been that long!!! I didn’t opt for anything except #4 CD’s as I didn’t think the upgrades would be worth the cost. Noted that you like listening in recording order – me too – and in 1972, my college roomate and I started a ‘playlist’ of exactly that – on reel-to-reel. (and we didn’t have the wonderful Lewishon tome to work from…). The basis was the Odean pressings -considered superior to the EMI at the time and we sort of thumbed our noses at the Capitol versions. To prove nothing changes, I recently started on a similar ‘playlist’ in iTunes for Magical Mystery Tour – coined ‘Tragical History Tour’ and doing an alternate album with then all the songs in their earliest iterations. Thanks to your books, I also re-created your ‘Capitol’ versions playlist of Rubber Soul/ Yesterday & Today/ Revolver – great listening!! Keep up the good work Bruce!!

Leave a Comment

The maximum upload file size: 25 MB. You can upload: image, audio, video, document, spreadsheet, interactive, text, archive, code, other. Drop file here